JPLOP.COM

by **Mixi** » Tue Feb 03, 2015 11:06 am

No song is sacred. You can't "steal" a song from anyone just by performing it.

by **koregaboku** » Tue Feb 03, 2015 11:21 am

Plus we've seen that no songs are off limit. Even if they were originated by scandaled OGs.

by **AyuHikaru** » Tue Feb 03, 2015 11:36 am

Mixi wrote:No song is sacred. You can't "steal" a song from anyone just by performing it.

I dunno Sayu sure thought it was sacred. They were gonna have riho replace Reina when she was out sick once and Sayu was like "NO THATS 6th GENS SONG" and sang it solo.

by **BerryzCelebration** » Tue Feb 03, 2015 12:12 pm

Yeah but that's Sayu though. She's not working with H!P anymore and has gone inactive, so if the 3rd gen were to perform, she can't just step in and say "NO THIS IS THE 6TH GEN SONG!!".

It's probably a special song for Sayu and they granted her that opportunity since she was one of the only remaining 6th gen and was leader, but really, for the company it's just another song.

by **koregaboku** » Tue Feb 03, 2015 12:58 pm

I agree. UF/HP has a vast catalogue of songs and it's stupid for them not to use it. Sooner or later all the songs seem to come up. If older songs weren't supposed to be sung it'd kinda defeat the purpose of MM keeping their discography along if their repertoire is supposed to refresh each time girls join or leave.

by **Mixi** » Tue Feb 03, 2015 1:26 pm

When members leave, their songs become a part of H!P's legacy. Should anyone stop performing Ayaya's songs just because she was a "legend"? Is Furusato sacred because it was Nacchi's song? Should Coconuts Musume songs fall into oblivion? Generation-specific songs (and solos) like Suki na Senpai and Ooki Hitomi will never stop being 5th and 6th gen songs and ANGERME 3rd gen, MM 12th gen can perform them all they want. It would be a shame if great songs were retired just because their original performers graduated. In a way, performing old songs is a tribute to H!P's heritage.

I'm very happy Country Girls exist because it means Country Musume's catalogue will be brought back to life. And bring on ANGERME 3rd gen's Ooki Hitomi.

by **321BreakinOut** » Tue Feb 03, 2015 2:24 pm

Coconuts songs DID fall into oblivion though. They were shit

by **AyuHikaru** » Tue Feb 03, 2015 2:35 pm

321BreakinOut wrote:Coconuts songs DID fall into oblivion though. They were shit

You're wrong.

by **321BreakinOut** » Tue Feb 03, 2015 2:39 pm

You're deaf

by **AyuHikaru** » Tue Feb 03, 2015 2:40 pm

oh no, I can absolutely hear how wrong you are.

JPLOP.COM

Hello! Project's Station '25 ~YT · TV · Radio · Magazines~

Re: H!P TV, Radio, Magazines, Hello! Station

Re: H!P TV, Radio, Magazines, Hello! Station

Re: H!P TV, Radio, Magazines, Hello! Station

Re: H!P TV, Radio, Magazines, Hello! Station

Re: H!P TV, Radio, Magazines, Hello! Station

Re: H!P TV, Radio, Magazines, Hello! Station

EXCEPT AYAKA AND MIKA OF COURSE

Re: EXCEPT AYAKA AND MIKA OF COURSE

Re: H!P TV, Radio, Magazines, Hello! Station

Re: H!P TV, Radio, Magazines, Hello! Station

Who is online