JPLOP.COM

Whaaaaa... Sugiyama Hiroki (Blue) directed Tentenko's MV? That's cool. Bummer he didn't win.

Shuhei's (Red) MVs are not all weird

Blue was cuter than Red, but I know that doesn't qualify him to win the contest

aww I wanted Green to win, I really liked Emi's interpretation!

I think that fit with the whole "selfish game of love" thing, and it had the right amount of close-ups. The girls acting was good as well.
I just didn't like the glitching effect. The rain scenes were so cool and I enjoyed the editing.

Blue had cool close-ups and I liked the effects but a bit slow.

I thought Red was way too gimmicky, and I don't like food and idols. Or the giant dancer at the end. But it was fun.

I wouldnt be surprised if there was a big difference between the Promotion Ver, and the Music video that they use for the next single.

waaaahh I'm looking forward to see the next Morning Musume's MV
The red entry was quite unique and fun !!
The green entry was sexy
The blue entry was awesome

I liked the Green Entry best as well Red was just... I think if it had actually had anything to do with the lyric or theme I'd like it more. Though I assume he'd do that for his real video. This seemed more like him going: I have this cool idea and no matter what song it is I'm gonna make it work. Kudos to the girls not breaking out into laughter though at some of those scenes. (like Kudou cutting the steak).

Blue - cliche idol rooftop scenes, pretty close-ups, not enough dance shots.
Red - unique and creative green screen. angles, spacing, and close-ups need work
Green - not a fan of black and white or the letterbox borders. surprised that the girl director chose to use sexy ero scenes. the members outfits getting soaked. ok..glad that Haga Akane wasn't in this.

none of the MVs fit Morning Musume. '15 EDM formation dance image. the original Wagamama Kinomama Ai no Joke MV is still the best. only one director that would probably understand their image would be blue. The sexy image is not their style, and the red one is a green screen user.

Red only won because of the excess amount of Riho

Red is for sure my least favorite video, but I can see why people voted for him.

I would have much rather had blue or green win, but I hope an A-side is a fun theme to match that style.

Hmmmm... not sure how to judge the music videos. As Amped said, none of the three has the spirit of Wagamama, but even so, all the three are good, very good MVs. First one had a plain boring (or even despairing) background, that straight-white-sunny mood wasn't a good choice for a MM video, not to talk about Wagamama. Second one is obviously for something quite more funny and for a not-in-the-cool-zone song, but yes, the guys knows his stuff with animation. And third and last is for a more slowly paced song with more minor scales in my opinion, though it had the best image editing out of the three.
I see why red is the winner, but... let's hope the MV he'll direct doesn't really get to be something random. That would be out of the current group's style. Or.. well, there is a possibility for quite some randomness but it'll be difficult to put it in place with the formation. Hmmmm.